Scarlett Mae and her friend Kiara Cole are getting ready for an Easter party when their giggles attract Ricky Spanish's attention. He bursts into Scarlett's room and tries to ask his stepsister and her friend when the party is starting. Scarlett makes it clear that Ricky needs to get out because he's not invited to anything. Later, Ricky gets back at the girls by coloring his balls like an Easter egg and putting them in a basket for them to lick. He hides beneath a blanket and waits for the girls to come in. They follow the instructions and lick the eggs, but their treat is salty, not sweet.

While the girls are discussing the egg, Ricky shifts so his dick is in the basket. When Kiara spies it, she suggests that they take turns sucking it. They both assume that it's Kiara's boyfriend since they've previously discussed having a threesome. Eventually Scarlett wants more, so she pushes her teddy's crotch aside and hops on for a stiffie ride. She keeps it up until she cums, which is when she finally learns that she's been fucking her stepbrother the whole time.

The girls retreat to the bathroom where they collect themselves. They may have been fooled, but Ricky's hardon has got them both so horny they start making out! Soon Kiara has her face and fingers buried in Scarlett's juicy twat. They want some D in their lovemaking, though, so they eventually decide to go back to the living room to give Ricky his lucky day. Faced with a threesome, Ricky plays stud to both his sister and her friend until finally blowing his load in his stepsis's fuck hole. She claims she's not on birth control, which freaks Ricky out and leaves both girls laughing that they've gotten the final word in their strangely sexual prank war.